Paris · Belle Époque

The Houses

of tolerance, around 1900

A door beneath a large number, closed shutters, sometimes a red lantern. Behind it, a salon with mirrors, a piano, women entered in a police register. This page describes the rules, the places, the words and the traces of that world, and also says what its elegance left in the shadows.

9
The threshold

Tolerated, never legal

Under the Third Republic, prostitution is not forbidden, and yet no law gives the houses a legal status. The Prefecture of Police tolerates them, controls them and keeps files on them. This is regulationism, a French system that Parent-Duchâtelet theorised in 1836: supervise rather than suppress. He compares prostitutes to the sewers of a great city, an evil the administration deems inevitable and wants to channel.

From the street, a maison de tolérance is recognised by its number painted large, lit at night, and by its closed shutters. That shuttered front probably explains the expression “maison close”, the closed house.

9
Schematic drawing of a façade. The number and a sliver of light are the only signs visible from the street.
The rules

What the police demanded

Ordinances change with prefects and periods. Here are the principles that come up most often, to be confirmed in the texts of the period you are interested in.

General principles

  • The house is run by a woman, often a former resident, registered with the Prefecture of Police and answerable for what happens there.
  • Each resident appears in the registers of the vice squad, with her identity and her date of entry.
  • Regular medical visits check the women, never the clients. A woman deemed ill is sent to the infirmary of the Saint-Lazare prison.
  • The house stays invisible: shutters closed, frosted panes, no soliciting from the window or on the pavement. The number and, as the case may be, the lantern are enough.
  • Outings are limited to certain days and take place in the company of the mistress of the house.
  • Distances must be kept from schools and churches. Age rules vary from one period to another.
Register · diagramNameAgeEntryMedical visitsRemarks
Diagram of the form of a register. No real page is reproduced and no name is written in.
The houses

Four ways of keeping a house

Luxury

Padded salons, themed rooms, high prices. Le Chabanais, 12 rue Chabanais, opened in 1878 by the madam known as Madame Kelly, is the model. Its Japanese room is said to have won an award at the 1900 Exposition Universelle.

Neighbourhood

A simpler salon, regulars, a modest price. Most establishments look like this, far from themed rooms and passing clients.

High turnover

The so-called maisons d'abattage: numbered tickets, quick turns, a clientele of soldiers and workers. Elegance there is reduced to a few mirrors and some lighting.

Maisons de rendez-vous

No number on the front, very discreet. Women come there when called by the madam and partly escape the regime of the houses.

Outside the houses, the “filles en carte”, registered women, live on their own and attend their health checks at the police. The “insoumises”, who refuse registration, risk arrest.

The plan

A house in cross-section

The ground floor is made to be seen and the upper floors not to be. The salon occupies the largest room, right by the entrance. The staircase leads to the bedrooms, away from the eyes of the street.

BedroomsBedroomsLinen roomSecond floorBedroomThemed roomBathroomFirst floorHallSalonmirrors, velvet, pianoDining roomkitchenOfficeof the mistressGround floorStairs9Street
Typical cross-section, drawn for this page, unrelated to any real plan. The tinted rooms are those the client sees.
An evening

From the pavement to the small hours

  1. The threshold

    You ring. Someone opens, sometimes a doorman, often a maid. Above the door, the number burns by gas or electricity, depending on the house.

  2. The salon

    Velvet, mirrors, sometimes a piano. The residents wait in light dress. The client sits down and is offered a drink, most often champagne, sold dear.

  3. The choice

    It is made with a glance, under the watch of the mistress, who sets the price and takes the money.

  4. Going up

    The couple goes up to a room. Payment has taken place downstairs, in some houses against a token struck with the establishment's name.

  5. Leaving

    You go out by the same door and the street becomes ordinary again. Inside, the mistress records the takings. The woman's share, once her expenses are deducted, is often slim.

The voices

Words and sentences

“We went there every evening, around eleven o'clock, as one goes to the café, quite simply.”
Maupassant, La Maison Tellier, 1881 — our translation

It is the first sentence of the short story. It makes the house a neighbourhood habit, almost a café life. Maupassant is in the public domain: the full French text can be read on Wikisource.

Other voices to read: Edmond de Goncourt, La Fille Élisa (1877); Huysmans, Marthe (1876); Yves Guyot, La Prostitution (1882), for the critique of the system; Léo Taxil, La Prostitution contemporaine (1884), to be read with suspicion, its author being a notorious hoaxer.

Maison de tolérance
An establishment tolerated by the police, with no legal existence.
Tenancière, maîtresse
The woman who runs the house. Also called “madame”.
Pensionnaire
A woman housed and fed in the house, who must repay her expenses.
Passe
A paid visit.
La montée
The move from the salon to the bedroom.
Fille en carte
A registered woman living outside the houses, under health control.
Insoumise
An unregistered woman, liable to arrest.
Abattage
High-turnover operation, by tickets and quick turns.
The other side

What the salon hid

Belle Époque imagery loves mirrors and velvet. Historians, from Alain Corbin to Laure Adler, describe a system in which women are filed, examined, held by a debt to the mistress, since lodging, dresses and meals are all billed, while the client is never checked.

The sexual freedom attributed to this world is above all that of the clients. Many historians read in the elegant codes, the politeness of the salon and the champagne a way of making a relationship of money and control acceptable.

Criticism comes early: Yves Guyot in 1882, the abolitionists including the Englishwoman Josephine Butler, then an extra-parliamentary commission set up in 1902. The system nevertheless holds until the Marthe Richard law, in 1946.

The traces

Where to look, what to read

This page reproduces no painting, no photograph and no press cutting. Reliable reproductions are with the museums and on Gallica, and an invented cutting would be a forgery.

Degas

A series of monotypes on the brothels, made towards the end of the 1870s.

Images: Wikimedia Commons

Toulouse-Lautrec

The paintings of the salon of the rue des Moulins (1894) and the album of lithographs Elles (1896). Several versions, in Albi and abroad, to be checked.

Images: Wikimedia Commons

Brassaï

Le Paris secret des années 30, published in 1976: photographs of establishments at the end of the regulated period.

Musée d'Orsay

The catalogue of the exhibition Splendeurs et misères. Images de la prostitution, 1850-1910 (2015) brings together historians' essays and reproductions.

musee-orsay.fr

Newspapers

Gil Blas, Le Courrier français and Le Rire, boulevard and satirical papers, are digitised. Search for “maisons de tolérance”.

gallica.bnf.fr

Archives

The archives of the Prefecture of Police hold the vice squad's records: registers, files, reports. Consultation on request.

Listening

Three movements

At the turn of the century, Satie accompanies café-concert singers on the piano, among them Paulette Darty. His waltzes of 1901 to 1904 come from that period. The sequence follows the evening: the street, the salon, the end of the night.

The threshold

Entrance

  • Satie, “Le Piccadilly”March, 1904. The café-concert, the lit-up street.Listen
  • Satie, “La Diva de l'Empire”American intermezzo, 1904.Listen
  • Offenbach, Galop infernalOrphée aux enfers, 1858. The cancan, before the door.Listen
The salon

Waltzes

  • Satie, “Poudre d'or”Waltz, 1901.Listen
  • Satie, “Je te veux”Sung waltz, 1902, to words by Henry Pacory.Listen
  • Satie, “Tendrement”Sung waltz, 1902.Listen
  • Debussy, “La plus que lente”Slow waltz, 1910.Listen
End of the night

Slow pieces

  • Satie, Gymnopédie No. 11888.Listen
  • Satie, Gnossienne No. 11890.Listen
  • Ravel, Pavane pour une infante défunte1899.Listen
  • Debussy, “Clair de lune”Suite bergamasque, published in 1905.Listen

The links open a search, not a specific recording. Choose the performance you like.

Landmarks

Timeline

  1. 1836Parent-Duchâtelet publishes De la prostitution dans la ville de Paris, the founding text of regulationism.
  2. 1878Le Chabanais opens, rue Chabanais.
  3. 1882Yves Guyot publishes La Prostitution, a critique of regulation.
  4. 1900Exposition Universelle. The Chabanais's Japanese room is said to have won an award there.
  5. 1902Extra-parliamentary commission on the regime of morals.
  6. 1924The One-Two-Two opens, rue de Provence. It belongs to the interwar years, not to the period of this page.
  7. 1946The Marthe Richard law: the maisons de tolérance close. There are then around 177 houses in Paris and 1,500 in France, according to common estimates.
Further reading

Books

  • Alain Corbin, Les Filles de noce (1978), the reference work on regulated prostitution.
  • Laure Adler, La Vie quotidienne dans les maisons closes, 1830-1930.
  • Jill Harsin, Policing Prostitution in Nineteenth-Century Paris.
  • Dominique Kalifa, Les Bas-fonds. Histoire d'un imaginaire (2013), on representations.
  • Exhibition catalogue Splendeurs et misères, Musée d'Orsay, 2015.
  • Parent-Duchâtelet, De la prostitution dans la ville de Paris (1836), on Gallica.

Text written from memory and partly cross-checked against a few online sources, including the Wikipedia article on Le Chabanais. Dates and figures are to be confirmed in the works cited. The drawings on this page are original and schematic.